Agency Goes To The Active, Or How Putin Doesn’t Understand How The World Works.

During the early days of the Crimean annexation episode, US President Barack Obama famously accused Russian President Vladimir Putin of “not understanding how the world works.” Given that the USA has never in its history understood anything about the world outside of its borders and has merely launched attack after attack on foreign lands from its cozy and resource wealthy island before returning to its isolated ignorance, this is pretty lulzy. It’s sorta like the cavalier 6-year-old telling his school principal how class should work, or the University student telling the Department Head how research funds should best be allocated.

This being somewhat obvious for the well educated reader, let’s still delve into the specifics for the sake of completeness. Let’s look at what Putin can teach Obama and the raft of other “progressive” Westerners about how to run a country.

1. Industry: Putin’s increasingly strong ties with China and Germany have positioned Russian industries to take advantage of two of the strongest production economies in the world. China and Germany are basically giant factories requiring a constant supply of natural resources. As Russia’s largest industries are coal, oil, and gas, it has exactly what those countries need. The new Chinese gas pipeline deals are particularly notable for not only their size and scale but also their use of direct currency swaps that bypass USD.

2. Currency: Speaking of currency, while the Ruble has taken a bit of a beating on the FX markets of late,i and despite all the scare-mongering tawk of “capital flight” in the Western press, the Russian Central Bank is injecting just a fraction of the liquidity into its economy that the Americans and Chinese are.ii Russians who were holding foreign currency in foreign banks were taught a lesson from the events in Cyprus in 2013.

Putin has also been stock-piling physical gold at record levels, deepening his country’s financial reservesiii as Western nations pile on debt up to their eyeballs and beyond. The Russian federal government’s debt-to-GDP level is a paltry 13% compared to the US’ 101%, Germany’s 77%, and Canada’s 89%.

Earlier this year, Putin also founded the New Development Bank (NDB) in coordination with the other BRICS nations. With a $100 bn non-USD-denominated currency pool earmarked for new infrastructure projects, the NDB is designed to extract these nations from the clutches of the IMF.

3. Taxation: Starting in 2001, Vladimir Putin instituted a flat federal personal income tax of just 13%… and the only local/regional taxes are on property and vehicles!iv Compare this to progressive taxation systems with upper personal income tax brackets in Germany (45%), USA (40%), and Canada (55%).v

For capital gains tax, Russia only hits its citizens at a modest 13% and only if the asset is held less than 3 years. Other Russian taxes include Value Added Tax of 18%; Unified Social Tax (for welfare programs) of 26% on the first 415,000 Rubles earned; Excise Tax for alcohol, tobacco, and fuel; Corporate Profit Tax of 20% with 18% going directly to regional budgeting; Mineral Resource Extraction Tax; Water

To sum up this rather lengthy intro to Russian economics, I’ll turn to Mr. Orlov:

Financially, Russia’s position is so solid that even the three Western credit ratings agencies don’t have the gall to downgrade Russia’s rating, sanctions notwithstanding. This is a country that is aggressively paying down its foreign debt, is running a record-high budget surplus, has a positive balance of payments, is piling up physical gold reserves, and not a month goes by that it doesn’t sign a major international trade deal (that circumvents the US dollar). In comparison, the US is a dead man walking: unless it can continue rolling over trillions of dollars in short-term debt every month at record-low interest rates, it won’t be able to pay the interest on its debt or its bills. Good-bye, welfare state, hello riots.

In modern times, the separation of church and state is largely an American construct.vii Various forms of Christianity have, for over a millenium, found themselves on the right side of Europe’s Kings and Queens. While the Soviets severed the close Tsarist ties to the Orthodox Church, Putin, himself basptised as a boy, has done much to reestablish this connection. Many Russians – just like many Muslims and Jews – don’t rationally segregate “religion” into a category distinct from cultural, social, and political organisation. Talking to God, much less being talked to about God, for two hours on Sunday and ignoring Biblical teachings the rest of the week is as American as apple pie, as modern as Canberra, and, for many in the Orthodox faith, as alien as the moon.

The separation of Church and State is, for most people, undesirable. This distinction doesn’t magically give people the shepherds they need, so their personal search for meaning has to be fulfilled by something else. In a “progressive” society, this ends up being Science,viii the Golden Calf, the State, or a mix of all three. While there’s little doubt that Russians love their Western luxury brands, Putin is proving to be a strong shepherd in his own right and his alignment with the Orthodox Church smartly extends his power to a much broader demographic.ix

Political freedoms:
Bizarre as this may sound to the Western reader, Russians seem to enjoy being treated like zeks. Freedom of speech and the rest of our “rights railroads” seem to be low on the priority list for Russians. For them, higher priorities include faith, food, occupation, and survival. So, no, gay marriage and marijuana aren’t about to be made legal is Russia any time soon, and there’s nothing unhappy, unfair, or unjust about this. That’s just your crusty Western lens getting in the way.

Territorial expansion:
Uniting ethnic Russians, as per Solzhenitsyn’s 1990 essay entitled Rebuilding Russia,x is a priority for Putin. Rightfully so. The borders “Russia” currently maintains don’t encompass many predominately Russian populations in the area, including those in Latvia, Ukraine, Uzbekistan, Belarus, and Kazakhstan. I wouldn’t be surprised if Putin continued to annex portions of “other countries” that he sees containing his fellow Russians.

Remind me again, how is uniting a people “not understanding how the world works”?

Public Relations:
Whereas Obama plays golf and waddles like a penguin down the red carpet, Putin can be seen riding horseback shirtless, hosting the Sochi games without a hiccup, hosting his country’s first F1 race just last month,xi and, in 2018, hosting the World Cup of Football.

In summa: What Putin understands better than any leader in the Western World is this: Action matters, action is non-negotiable, and to the active goes the agency.

Since the most recent Syrian civil war began, what with Obama’s “If you cross this line, I swear I’ll do something” followed by his “I’m very disappointed that you crossed that line. I think you should know that,” the US has ceased to be a going concern in international affairs. Sure, they can still print money by the bucketloads, flooding every street with fake wealth and generally distorting natural incentive systems, but this too shall come to pass.

The US has probably never understood “how the world works” and, without some serious scholarship, probably won’t anytime soon. This won’t stop Putin, intent on maintaining a large nation state in the midst of Computer Times, from distancing himself from the nouveaux riches diktats of the West.xii

With his understanding of economics, religion, capitalism, diplomacy, and his peoples’ dispositions, Putin is poised to stretch out his legacy well beyond his already impressive 15-year reign. He seems like he could keep rocking for another decade or more.

For the record, while I personally maintain an intellectual interest in Russian literature, I have zero desire to live in Russia. Dissidents with blogs can have all kinds of polonium-flavoured “problems” there.xiii At the same time, viewed from the Bitcoin castle in the sky, Russia’s resurgence under Putin is a pleasure to watch, not least of all because it wipes the smug smile off the face off Team America.

To the extent that Putin wants to pretend like La Serenissima was never created, and to the extent that he wants to wants to unify and organise his people into a single nation state, he sure seems to knows a thing or two about how the world works.

___ ___ ___

  1. Some people blame oil prices, which are currently at $66.15 for WTI and $70.15 for Brent. A barrel of crude was over $100 this past summer.
  2. The Russian Central bank injected ~$70 bn into its economy in all of 2014, or less than the US Federal Reserve created ex nihilo every fucking month under QE3, the most recent but hardly the last round of US QE. The People’s Bank of China is basically on par with the Fed, as far as we know.
  3. As best he knows how. Putin’s still a bit slow on the uptake vis-a-vis Bitcoin.
  4. Seriously. Can you fucking imagine how sweet that would be??
  5. The province of Quebec has a progressive income tax with an upper bracket of, sit down for this, 25.75%, on top of the federal 29%. Alberta has a flat personal income tax of 10% and is also the only province without a Provincial Sales Tax (PST), which typically range from 6-9%.
  6. A water tax in Oilberta would put an end to the oil sands cashcow faster than you can say “Athabasca River.” If $50 crude doesn’t kill it first…
  7. The Khans of AD 1200-1370 were also quite permissive of various religions and specifically chose not to align themselves with any single religious denomination in particular. The Mongols were cherry-pickers, incorporating the best ideas and technologies from both West and East. While this open-minded ideology served to create a prosperous society at the time, we have few physical monuments to remember them by.
  8. And its bastard brother, Statistics.
  9. Notably, the Russian Orthodox Church is the second-largest Church on the planet with some 200 mn adherents.
  10. Rebuilding Russia PDF: original
  11. You can watch Putin shake hands with Russian Grand Prix winner Lewis Hamilton at 2:48 of this race review.
  12. From Orlov:

    Pardon the analogy, but this is the way nouveaux riches behave when they suddenly end up with a great fortune, in this case, in the shape of world leadership and domination. Instead of managing their wealth wisely, for their own benefit too of course, I think they have committed many follies.

  13. Eg. Mr. Artyom Borovik:  “Borovik died in 2000 in a still-unsolved Moscow plane accident days after producing a scathing article about an ascendant Russian politician, Vladimir Putin, who was about to become president. Borovik quoted Putin in an article as saying, “There are three ways to influence people: blackmail, vodka, and the threat to kill.”

32 thoughts on “Agency Goes To The Active, Or How Putin Doesn’t Understand How The World Works.

  1. Zeke says:

    Putin is a master of realpolitik in pursuit of national interest in a zero-sum world. I’m not sure it’s worth ascribing any particular strategy to Obama. Not because he lacks a view of US national interest, or a strategy for achieving it. But rather, he has only limited ability to shape how the foreign policy and national security bureaucracies in our country pursue their own goals. Putin is a chess grand master playing multiple opponents in a demonstration match. Obama is one of those opponents, but he sent a stand-in to play his side, and if you asked him, he probably thinks the game is checkers.

    • Pete D. says:

      he probably thinks the game is checkers.

      Ha. The ol’ “a board is a board” and “a map is a map” mistake. This’d be the same braindamage that led the USG and its various banking tendrils to make projection after projection until kaboom! no more US economy. Those nouveaux riches…

  2. Peter Lambert says:

    In the summary: “but this too shall come to pass” – I think you meant “but this too shall pass”. The first one means the thing will happen in the future, the second means it is happening now but will end.

  3. […] “curing” of hierarchy, a bit telling? Aren’t the stories villanising bankers and Russia just a bit […]

  4. […] progressives. And it never fucking works because it ultimately tries to protect the passive from the active, which is, quite simply, thermodynamically […]

  5. […] and if your fortune required any hustle whatsoever to achieve, that is, any reasonable amount of agency and understanding of how the world works, is that you won’t last 6 months of idleness. It’s too […]

  6. […] The “few other pretty smart things” included privatising government liquor stores and vehicle registries, greatly reducing the number and size of loan guarantees issued to corporations, and generally letting businesses take care of matters of business. Not bad for a high-school drop-out and a drunk, eh? He actually understood how the world works! […]

  7. […] nuclear engineers and/or suicide bombers and/or military guys mircea_popescu: You don’t understand how the world works […]

  8. […] knows as a “prune,” it’s just that the USians were pulling their usual “words equal reality” trick in a vain attempt to cater to the […]

  9. […] – ever since we developed willful agency and recognised our finite existence, and thus extract ourselves from the jungle of animalistic […]

  10. […] for her book club, one that seemed to denounce its existence, and had found the arguments against agency quite compelling. At the time, we scratched the surface of complex systems and epistemic opacity, […]

  11. […] of your existence doesn’t provide sufficient breadth and context with which to exert your agency upon the world. From this hedged-in vantage point, blindered and bound, being an -ist for an -ism […]

  12. […] everything unravelled. Is this at all surprising ? Given the differences between the strong-handed Putin and the limp-wristed Obama, to say nothing of the differences between La Serenissima and […]

  13. […] that to the active goes the agency helps me to overcome my natural inclination to watch from the sidelines. […]

  14. […] to the productivity of the institution, be it a business or a larger social fabric, driving activity over passivity as it […]

  15. […] you have control, if you have agency, this all might seem painfully obvious. But if you don’t, did you notice how easy, efficient, […]

  16. […] when your dick is so and you’re materially lacking the virility needed to fight against the real world the way it actually works, and you’d rather not recall that the slogan “Making America Great Again” implies […]

  17. […] explanation is, of course, that the cars are lumps of shit welded together by apes and that Putin isn’t an idiot. […]

  18. […] at least enough to actually make sense. Then again, maybe I just don’t understand how the world works. […]

  19. […] the passive desire nothing more than the mercy and more importantly the attention of the active should come as no surprise. But hey, lotsa flotsam “whent too unavericity” and now […]

  20. […] also worth noting that, quite like Mr. “Doesn’t understand how the world works,” I don’t personally wear a helmet on my bike either. Why ? Isn’t that, like, […]

  21. […] mkay, strap a fresh petrol tank on your flamethrower and get to torchin’. Agency goes to the active, life’s for the living, and all that other good […]

  22. […] unfamiliar within the animal kingdom. Justice and justification don’t require words, merely action. Is that too much for a praxeologist to grok […]

  23. […] can do it too, of course! For as long as you have agency, which, while being statistically unlikely for netizens in general, is ever-so-slightly less […]

  24. […] Since I’m sadly not a foreign dignitary from any recognised “legitimate” “non-terrorist” nation, I was unable to enter what could only be the most nearly-priceless house in town without a guided tour. The English-language tour was an hour-long wait, overbooked at all, and there was nothing to do in the interim but get more soaking wet. Thankfully the French tour started almost immediately and was attended by just myself and two women from Martinique. Our guide, seen below imitating a T-Rex, was full of useless and frankly incorrect trivia about how the GG was “apolitical” and didn’t interfere with “ourdemocracy” unless he/sheii had a “very strong reason” for doing so and that this “almost never” happened anyways so don’t even worry about it. Uh-huh. I’m sure that’s how the world works. […]

  25. […] ask anyone actually successful, from Shakespeare to Martin Shkreli whether agency goes to the active or not. […]

  26. […] so existentially unpleasant is its mere possibility. So it’s the world that doesn’t understand, it’s the world that broken, and it’s the world that’s an emergency room in such […]

  27. […] horribly and lose their lives for their troubles – but the dynamic is what’s important. The agency goes to the active because the penetrator takes the risk for the reward. Maybe he fucks an electrical socket. But […]

  28. […] Listen to the titans of modernity such as Le Corbu or Niemeyeri and they’ll tell you it’s a city planned for grandiosity, monumentality, top-down efficiency, and an unsettling sense of placelessness, all sprinkled with an honesty of materialsii and minimalism of stylistic adornment. But (most) architects aren’t builders,iii and who asked the overgrown cartoonists anything, right ? We’d better ask the people who really know how the world works, democratically elected governments! […]

  29. […] on the possibility of Trump amending the Constitution to allow himself a third termiv – à la Putin – drop a comment […]

  30. […] isn’t orthodoxy, it’s orthopraxy Orthopraxy isn’t posting, it’s sacrificing Sacrificing isn’t burning, it’s glory before G-d Glory before […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *